VILLAIN
 TOTAL VOTES
The Joker (Cesar Romero)

224
The Penguin (Burgess Meredith)

55
Catwoman (Julie Newmar)

 159
Catwoman (Eartha Kitt)

37
The Riddler (Frank Gorshin)

 109
King Tut (Victor Buono)

30
The Mad Hatter (David Wayne)

14
Ma Parker (Shelley Winters)

15
Egghead (Vincent Price)

22
Shame (Cliff Robertson)

20
Louie The Lilac (Milton Berle)

5
Chandell (Liberace)

25
The Archer (Art Carney)

51
The Siren (Joan Collins)

30
The Minstrel (Van Johnson)

34
Zelda or Olga (Anne Baxter)

14